Switch year: 2026 2025 2024 2023 Jeremy Peters — all years → all 2024 picks →
Initial Grade
B-
at draft day · 62.6
Current Grade
B-
latest snapshot · 64.1

Roger's Reviews

Post Rookie Draft — initial reaction, no performance data

Ladies and gentlemen, the league office has completed its review of the Not That Drunk 2024 rookie draft, and I am prepared to render judgment. Jeremy Peters — the man who has made more trades than some people have had hot meals — walks away with a B-minus, which is exactly the grade you'd expect from someone who panic-reached a full seven slots early on that 2.11 pick and somehow thought no one would notice. The 4.04 is the saving grace here: twelve slots of pure, uncut value, the kind of steal that makes Roger… moderately impressed, which is more than he gives most of you. The 4.02 reach — fourteen goddamn slots — is the type of move that gets you a strongly-worded letter from the league office and a long look in the mirror. Per Article 11, Section 3(c)(ii) of the Dynasty Operations Manual, a B-minus is not a failing grade, but in a league where Jeremy's burning trades like campfire kindling, he's going to need those later picks to develop fast… or at least faster than his judgment did on day two of this draft.

Year-End Retrospective — with performance baked in

Ladies and gentlemen, the league office has completed its formal post-mortem review of the Not That Drunk 2024 rookie draft class, and the verdict is — fine. Just fine. Jeremy Peters, the most trade-happy bastard in this league, somehow sat on his hands long enough to accumulate five picks and walked away with a B-minus, which is frankly better than his average finish suggests he deserves. The crown jewel here is Isaac Guerendo — snagged at 4.08 like he was an afterthought, composite of 70, performance score of 76 — a late-round dart that actually hit something other than the wall. The low point, per the official record, is Ben Sinnott: looked promising on draft day, performance score of 55 says he's been about as electric as a Packers playoff run… which, per Article 11, Section 3(c), is not a compliment. Jalen McMillan also turned in a 47 performance score, which the league office is choosing not to dwell on for reasons of professional courtesy. On further review, 18 career trades and this is the draft class Jeremy is most proud of — Roger isn't entirely sure what that says, but it probably says something.

Class Composite Over Time

How this draft class has aged. Each point is a snapshot — pure draft-day grade, then end-of-each-season recomputes.

Picks

PickPlayerPosNFL InitialCurrentΔ
2.09 Ben Sinnott TE WAS B (72) B- (62)
2.11 Ja'Tavion Sanders TE CAR C+ (59) B- (65)
4.02 Tyrone Tracy RB NYG C (43) B- (66)
4.04 Jalen McMillan WR TBB B (76) C+ (59)
4.08 Isaac Guerendo RB SFO B- (61) B- (70)

Per-Pick Grade History

How each individual pick's grade has evolved across snapshots.

2.09 — Ben Sinnott (TE)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2024 72.11 B 72.11 -
End of 2024 60.66 B- 72.11 43 (2024)
End of 2025 61.57 B- 72.11 55 (2025)

2.11 — Ja'Tavion Sanders (TE)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2024 58.6 C+ 58.6 -
End of 2024 64.72 B- 58.6 74 (2024)
End of 2025 64.98 B- 58.6 69 (2025)

4.02 — Tyrone Tracy (RB)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2024 43.3 C 43.3 -
End of 2024 59.02 C+ 43.3 83 (2024)
End of 2025 66.28 B- 43.3 82 (2025)

4.04 — Jalen McMillan (WR)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2024 75.9 B 75.9 -
End of 2024 78.58 B 75.9 83 (2024)
End of 2025 58.55 C+ 75.9 47 (2025)

4.08 — Isaac Guerendo (RB)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2024 61.0 B- 61.0 -
End of 2024 66.91 B- 61.0 76 (2024)
End of 2025 69.87 B- 61.0 76 (2024)