Switch year: 2026 2025 2024 2023 Taylor Hook & Blake Hoene — all years → all 2023 picks →
Initial Grade
B
at draft day · 74.3
Current Grade
B
latest snapshot · 72.9

Roger's Reviews

Post Rookie Draft — initial reaction, no performance data

Ladies and gentlemen, the league office has completed its official review of Franchise 4's 2023 rookie draft class — a name which, much like this franchise's creativity, remains tragically unclaimed. Their 1.03 pick came off the board two slots ahead of consensus, which, per Article 11, Section 3(c), constitutes a mild reach — not a fireable offense, but Roger is watching. The steal of the draft is their 2.03: a consensus 11 sliding to pick 15 is exactly the kind of patient, value-positive move that makes Blake and Taylor look briefly competent, and Roger will reluctantly acknowledge it. Then there's the 4.03 — a consensus rank of 69 taken at slot 39, which is a thirty-slot reach and frankly an affront to the shield… this is the pick that concerns the league office most, and frankly concerns Roger personally. A B- with a D-grade anchor dragging it down is exactly what you'd expect from a franchise that still hasn't named its team — steady enough to not embarrass themselves, reckless enough to remind everyone why they probably shouldn't be trusted.

Year-End Retrospective — with performance baked in

Ladies and gentlemen, the league office has completed its formal post-mortem on the Franchise 4 — yes, still called Franchise 4, no that never stops being embarrassing — 2023 rookie draft class. Their 1.03 pick stands as a genuine triumph, a composite grade of 95 that frankly exceeded what this office expected from two men who still haven't named their team. The 4.03 selection, meanwhile, earned a C-minus and a composite of 33, which is the kind of late-round dart that lands in the wall, slides down slowly, and hits the floor while everyone watches. The middle picks were fine — a B-minus and a C, the fantasy equivalent of ordering the second-cheapest wine at a restaurant and telling yourself you did great. Net result: C-plus, 58.71 composite, which is exactly the grade you'd expect from co-owners who put this much effort into choosing a team name.

Class Composite Over Time

How this draft class has aged. Each point is a snapshot — pure draft-day grade, then end-of-each-season recomputes.

Picks

PickPlayerPosNFL InitialCurrentΔ
1.03 Jahmyr Gibbs RB DET B+ (84) A+ (95)
2.03 Will Levis QB TEN B+ (83) B- (64)
3.03 Jalin Hyatt WR NYG B- (68) C (43)
4.03 Deuce Vaughn RB DAL D (29) C- (33)

Per-Pick Grade History

How each individual pick's grade has evolved across snapshots.

1.03 — Jahmyr Gibbs (RB)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2023 83.6 B+ 83.6 -
End of 2023 87.59 A- 83.6 94 (2023)
End of 2024 93.07 A 83.6 99 (2024)
End of 2025 95.25 A+ 83.6 98 (2025)

2.03 — Will Levis (QB)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2023 83.0 B+ 83.0 -
End of 2023 76.78 B 83.0 67 (2023)
End of 2024 68.91 B- 83.0 60 (2024)
End of 2025 64.22 B- 83.0 60 (2024)

3.03 — Jalin Hyatt (WR)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2023 68.0 B- 68.0 -
End of 2023 65.59 B- 68.0 62 (2023)
End of 2024 49.02 C 68.0 36 (2024)
End of 2025 42.69 C 68.0 36 (2024)

4.03 — Deuce Vaughn (RB)

SnapshotCompositeLetterDraft-timePerf (year)
Draft Day 2023 29.2 D 29.2 -
End of 2023 33.19 C- 29.2 39 (2023)
End of 2024 31.8 C- 29.2 34 (2024)
End of 2025 32.67 C- 29.2 34 (2024)