2023 Draft — Cougar Hunters

→

Ladies and gentlemen, the league office has completed its review of the Cougar Hunters' 2023 rookie draft class, and I will be brief. Ryan Harker takes the first overall pick — a consensus top-four talent — which is bold, fine, respectable, the kind of move that says we are here to compete, except Harker's career average finish is 8.25 and frankly the league office has questions. His Round 4 selection, however, is a goddamn catastrophe on paper — a player the consensus had sitting comfortably at 64, scooped at pick 37, which is a 27-slot reach and the sort of decision that gets made after someone's third drink at the draft board. The Round 2 and Round 3 adds are fine — slight overpays, nothing that warrants a formal inquiry, just the low-grade optimism of a man who needed a wide receiver. On further review, the league office grades this class a B- — Harker showed up, grabbed a first-rounder with upside and then immediately torched the goodwill with that fourth-round selection like he was daring us to notice. We noticed, Ryan. The Cougar Hunters are either about to turn a corner or they are going to finish ninth again, and Roger is not going to speculate further because his glass is empty.

Ladies and gentlemen, the league office has completed its official forensic audit of the 2023 Cougar Hunters rookie draft — and the findings are, frankly, more complicated than Ryan Harker deserves credit for. Bijan Robinson at 1.01 was the single greatest thing this franchise has ever done, a pick so correct it almost obscures the fact that Harker's team is otherwise a career bottom-feeder averaging a finish of eighth. Rashee Rice at 2.01 — also excellent, which means Ryan somehow nailed his first two picks and still couldn't find his way into a playoff bracket, a statistical achievement the league office intends to study for years. Then we get to Cedric Tillman at 3.01, the official worst pick of this class, a man who performed below his already-modest draft-day expectations and exists on rosters primarily as a reminder that hubris is a flat circle. A.T. Perry at 4.04 at least outperformed his draft slot, so Roger will give Harker a partial credit there — a late-round flier who became something resembling a fantasy asset is the one thing keeping this retrospective from being a eulogy. Final grade: B. Two elite picks, one bust, one late-round salvage job — and somehow Harker is still finishing eighth. The 2023 draft didn't fail the Cougar Hunters. The Cougar Hunters failed the 2023 draft.