2024 Pick 1.8
J.J. McCarthy (QB, MIN) — drafted by Dan Pratt (Red N' Mellow)
Current Grade
As of End of 2025 (using 2025 performance data).
B
composite score: 71.32
Consensus rank
8
nfl_draft_slot
Pick slot
8
overall in fantasy draft
Value delta
0
positive = fell to them
Draft-time score
82.0
team-need adj: 0
Performance score
64
positional percentile
Grade Over Time
How this pick has aged. Year 0 is heavily draft-time; performance signal grows each year.
| Snapshot | Composite | Letter |
|---|---|---|
| Draft Day 2024 | 82.0 | B+ |
| End of 2024 | 82.0 | B+ |
| End of 2025 | 71.32 | B |